Categories: Commentary

The Deputy is Essential?

The House of Assembly met on Monday 19th September 2011. The meeting started at 10am with the House Speaker in the chair and all the members of the House present bar one. The appointed deputy speaker was absent; he was in the Middle East on private business. Of course that was no reason not to proceed with the Order Paper: a motion to borrow $5 million dollars from a local bank for the purpose of constructing a purpose-built home for abused children.
With just one major matter on the Order Paper for the day the House meeting ended at 10:45 with the motion passed. Within minutes of the end of the House session word reached the parliament that the Deputy Speaker died in the Middle East at 9:45 am that same morning.
Well from all we have heard from some legal “experts” the motion to borrow $5 million can no longer be acted upon because the House was without a deputy speaker at the time it convened and therefore not properly constituted. Come on! There was no way the House could have known this. And if it did, should the House be adjourned and the day’s business abandoned for fear of resolving to act illegally if not out of a respect for the dead?
This is the new significance the deputy speaker has acquired if we are to accept the interpretation that nothing valid can come from the House during its life, in the absence of an appointed Deputy Speaker.
Is that what we mean when we say the law is an ass? Or are some trying very hard to make it one? I wonder what the courts would conclude?

Related Post
Claudius Coxwain

Recent Posts

Veteran Journalist Lissa Joseph Dies

The Saint Lucian media landscape is in mourning today following the heartbreaking news of the passing of Lisa Joseph. Read More

1 day ago

2025 General Election: Same 16–1 Result as 1997, Very Different National Message

By contrast, the 2025 election, led by Prime Minister Philip J. Pierre, was far more measured. It was neither a… Read More

3 weeks ago

Saint Lucia Is Not at a Crossroads: It Is at a Breaking Point

Will we accept a government that hides money, hides deals, and hides the truth while the nation collapses around it?… Read More

1 month ago

The Flip Side Of Philip Pierre’s Counterfeit Coin

Although oil prices have been trending downwards this Pierre Administration has not passed on any of the savings to the… Read More

1 month ago

Selective Statistics and Convenient Storytelling Do Not Make an Economic Success Story

When governments selectively highlight numbers, hide methodology changes, or use seasonal fluctuations to create the illusion of success, the public… Read More

1 month ago

At the Crossroads Again: Why Saint Lucia Must Choose Progress Over Partisan Reflex:

Caribbean electorates often vote governments out due to frustration.. Read More

1 month ago

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. No personally identifiable information is stored.